February 25, 2002


Home Page

Open Letter to the NTSB Chairman by Ray Lahr

by Victor Trombettas
Ray Lahr is a Graduate engineer from USC, former Navy pilot (WWII vintage), former Air Lines Pilots Association Safety Representative, and former United Airlines pilot.
Ray sent the following letter to the NTSB Chairman on February 24, 2002.

February 24, 2002
Captain Ray Lahr (ret.)
18254 Coastline Drive
Malibu, CA 90265
Marion C. Blakey, Chairman
National Transportation Safety Board
490 L'Enfant Plaza East, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20594

Dear Ms. Blakey:

In an article about AA587 titled, "Pilots Ask: How Much Rudder Is Too Much?" (Aviation Week 2/18/02 pg. 44), Frances Fiorino included this statement:

NTSB Chairman Marion C. Blakey stressed the cause of the accident is yet to be determined. What is known about AA587, she said, is that the aircraft experienced two wake encounters, and a series of rudder reversals on the aircraft led to the failure of the vertical stabilizer.

"It is unknown at this point if the rudder movements caused the stabilizer's failure or if the movements were caused by the pilots," Blakey emphasized.

As a retired airline pilot, I consider it exceedingly unlikely that an experienced pilot would make a series of rudder reversal inputs if the rudder was still attached to the aircraft and the rudder was responding properly. If the rudder itself had already separated from the aircraft, or if it was nonfunctional and was not responding to pilot inputs, then the pilot, in desperation, might have been making rudder pedal movements to counter whatever gyration the rudderless aircraft was experiencing.

Where were the above rudder reversals measured? Was it rudder pedal movement or was it actual deflection of the rudder itself? And if it was rudder deflection, was that deflection relative to the fuselage or relative to the vertical stabilizer which itself might have been deflecting? And do the rudder reversals correlate with lateral and rotational accelerations? The answers to these questions should be on the Flight Data Recorder. We are eagerly looking forward to the release of the Flight Data Recorder readout by the NTSB.

Ray Lahr

Please jump to the U.S.Read Home Page where you will see more links to Flight 587 stories.

Submit your email to the Editor. Please provide your full name, city, and state. Thanks for your comments!